Monday, July 30, 2012

Policy-FOOD SECURITY BILL: STRUCTURAL BOTTLENECKS

Though The Food Security Bill has been finally approved by a Group of Ministers to be presented before The Parliament, what might finally take shape as The National Food Security Act is being questioned. Will the entire idea of food security for all fructify?

To be fair to NAC, the purpose of the legislation on food security, which was earlier an exclusive premise of the NAC, actually lost its teeth soon after government bodies got involved in the process.

Debates began that unfortunately led to the NAC succumbing to political pressure. The whole case of ensuring ‘food for all’ was lost. However, there are still a few positives that emerge from this forward movement, says senior economic expert Suvrokamal Dutta. “Even if the legislation was to be approved in the current form, something which looks very unlikely, it is a big leap ahead. I agree there is a lot more that is to be done in this front... but target groups need to be clearly defined, and there should be a pan-India survey conducted for this purpose. The targeted PDS could prove as a bottleneck for the government while implementing the NFSA. Still, it is a significant move ahead,” he says.

Expecting NFSA to deliver the originally desired results is being too optimistic. But as said, the fact that there is a definite intent within the government to move along the philosophy of food for all, is itself one of the most noteworthy commitments of the political class.

Still, the politicisation of critical issues and the effects thereon, have started to show already. Just before the beginning of the Monsoon session of the Parliament, Food Minister K. V. Thomas declared that it was unlikely that the Bill would be introduced in the current session, adding that it would now be introduced in the winter session, extending the deadline for its implementation to sometime next year. With food inflation rising worldwide, experts are already worried not only about the delay in the bill, but also the funding required to support the same.

Many state governments will look to sort out their differences with the Bill, which is also set to take time. Even if the government is able to push the Bill through in the winter session, it’s not quite clear right now on how the project could include self-sustainability. In summary, it’s a great promise that has been shown to the Indian populace, yet it’s actual implementation remains a distant dream.

Draft dilutes existing entitlements

B&E: What are your major concerns regarding the Food Security Bill? Do you think the proposed legislation in its current form can attend to the food-for-all idea?
JD: The government’s draft of the proposed National Food Security Bill – apart from ignoring the demands of the entire right to food campaign – has junked many provisions of the draft prepared by the National Advisory Council and has also diluted the existing entitlements. The entire draft has been written with the objective of minimising obligations and restricting the extent and reach of the Bill. In fact, it makes a mockery out of the idea of food security for all.

B&E: The extent of beneficiaries of the proposed bill is an issue of concern. Your views on the proposal of legal entitlement to food grains only to priority households.
JD: It is the framework that is problematic. First, it hinges on a lasting division of the population into three groups, without any clarity as to how the groups are to be identified. In the absence of any obvious alternative, the NAC is effectively falling back on the BPL census to identify priority groups. This is a major setback as the NAC’s entire work began with a virtually unanimous rejection of BPL-based targeting for the PDS. Exclusion errors in earlier BPL censuses were very large, and the next BPL census is unlikely to fare much better, judging from the pilot survey. Also, the issue here is not just of the priority groups. There are millions of households which will receive no benefit at all.

B&E: PDS in India has been an area of concern. Do you think the system will be able to deliver? Can the Planning Commission’s view of adopting a system of cash transfers instead of providing subsidised food grains prove to be a good idea?
JD: I think the issue is a little different here. I agree that there is tremendous scope for PDS to improve in India. Having said that, a survey that we recently conducted covering over 100 villages across nine states, indicated an impressive revival of the PDS across the country. In fact, we have found that the PDS has become a lifeline for millions of rural households. However, the other side of the story is that the BPL list on which the benefits of the PDS are based on, is very defective. There are huge inclusion errors, which has severely reduced the effectiveness of the PDS as a tool of food security.

B&E: What other concerns do you have regarding the Bill?
JD: The Bill is set to go to the Parliament for discussion. So, I would not like to comment on what it would come out as. However, there are many provisions of the NAC that were later diluted, which is unfortunate. Still, I believe certain modifications could help the cause. First, the idea of a universal PDS in the poorest 200 districts could easily be reinstated by waiving exclusion criteria in these districts for an initial period. Second, the Act could be gradually extended to the whole country, over a period of, say, three years, starting with the poorest 200 districts. This will make it easier to meet the additional foodgrain requirements in a phased manner throughout India.


Saturday, July 28, 2012

4G Calling: Are we Ready?

Operators in India are still fixing the loose ends in their 3G networks but 4G technologies are already knocking on their doors.

The rollout of Fourth Generation, or 4G, services is the next big thing for India’s telecom sector. Operators like Reliance Industries, which has broadband wireless access (BWA) spectrum in all 22 telecom circles in India, are already chalking out plans. According to industry buzz, RIL is finalising vendors who would supply broadband equipment based on LTE technology for rolling out wireless broadband services by the end of this year. The other operators with BWA spectrum are also conducting trials to test 4G-based technologies. Qualcomm, Bharti Airtel, Aircel, Tikona and Reliance Infotel are some of the major players who own spectrum in the 2.3 Ghz band and are planning to launch 4G-based broadband services. The largest private telco, Bharti Airtel (which got BWA licence in just 4 circles), says that its 4G strategy depends on future allocations in 700Mhz and FDD 2.5Ghz bands and on its technology trials for BWA launch.

Fourth Generation telecom services are the next generation to the 3G and 2G families of cellular wireless standards and 4G is already the buzzword in many parts of the world. It is the next step in the evolution of mobile data transfer. The services are currently on offer globally by 64 telecom service providers in 31 countries. In the US, Sprint and T-Mobile have already launched 4G-based LTE networks. But in truth, 4G services as we know them today are more like 3.75G, or late stage 3G because “true 4G” networks are still in the works. The important thing, however, is that these networks are ready to be upgraded to full 4G once it arrives, which is expected between 2011 and mid-2012. Also, the underlying technology for providing 4G services is not the same. Sprint and T-Mobile, for example, use WiMax technology for their 4G network, while another player Verizon Wireless uses LTE. But irrespective of the choice of technology, 4G wireless is designed to deliver up to 100 Mbps of download speed and 50 Mbps of upload speed. On an average, 4G wireless today is anywhere from four to ten times faster than the existing 3G networks.

In India, full-fledged 4G services could be some years away as telecom operators continue to grapple with issues related to 3G infrastructure. So far, even the response to 3G rollout has not exactly been encouraging. Analysts estimate that India currently has 10 million 3G subscribers, or approximately 1.25% of the country’s total wireless subscriber base. While the number of 3G subscribers may be small, it is still significant considering that till date, there are only 11 million wireline broadband customers. Despite the poor quality of service to customers, the numbers are clearly on a rise and are expected to reach 142 million in 2015. Wireless networks have already started offering third generation capabilities, which provide benefits of increased data transfer speed and easier access to applications and Internet from mobile devices. The migration to 4G technologies (WiMax and LTE), which offer even better wireless connectivity speeds between 100 Mbps and 1 Gbps, is only to be expected. Predictably, more action on 4G is almost a certainty over the next couple of years as the demand for even more efficient data-centric services keeps growing. The trend is already visible in the increasing hordes of users accessing richer and more customised content, and asking for greater, faster and more efficient forms of delivery. Analysts project that by 2015, mobile internet traffic will increase to 23 Exabytes, which will be equivalent to 6.3 billion people downloading a digital book every day, 50% on laptops and the other 50% on small devices like mobile phones. As a result, the demand on laptop capacity would go up by 1000% and on small devices by 10,000%.


Friday, July 27, 2012

Is HUL Losing The India Plot?

From #22 in 2009 to #30 in 2010 and now #35 in B&E POwer 100 list. Onkar Pandey tries to find out where is HUL Going Wrong


Certainly, the first decade of the 21st century has been a rough ride for Hindustan Unilever. For one, it’s growth rate has taken a big beating. It hasn’t been able to double its revenue in the last 11 years; poor, considering its scorching pace in 90s, when in was doubling its revenue in every four to five years. Second, it’s no more the feared giant whose marketing skills scared lesser FMCG mortals. Now Players like ITC, P&G, Nestle, Dabur, Godrej Consumers and Marico are slowly and steadily nibbling away its market share in both home and personal care category.

A big reason for the same is the fact that the company has gone for quite a few leadership changes and strategy overhaul in the last decade, which though were course-corrective in nature, forced the company towards a fits and start growth, with each new leadership and strategy change. And now it seems something has really gone amiss with the FMCG giant. The shareholders have started earning less and less from HUL (EPS has gone down from Rs.11.46 in FY’09 to Rs.10.58 in FY’11), which might force them to stay away from the stock in future. Already, Goldman Sachs has further muddled the troubled water by downgrading HUL to “sell” from “neutral,” saying it will find it difficult to sustain strong volume growth in a highly competitive environment, while high input costs will continue to put pressure on margins. It’s profitability is showing continuous dip – from Rs.25 billion in 2008-09, it dropped over 11% in 2009-10 to Rs.22.07 billion. Though it managed to improve its bottomline in the last fiscal to Rs.23.06 billion, it’s just a marginal 4.7% rise.

But more than the profit figures, the real problem for HUL at present is that it has been consistently losing market share across categories. According to Euromonitor International, its market share has dropped from a high of 36.6% in 2005 to 33.3% in 2010 in the personal care segment. Going by individual brands the problem is more worrisome. Its classic brands like Fair & Lovely (down from 5.5% to 5.3%), Lux (5.1% to 4.3%), Lifebuoy (4.2% to 3.7%), Clinic Plus (2.4% to 2.1%), Close-Up (1.8% to 1.2%), Breeze (2.1% to 1.1%), have continuously declined from 2005 to 2010, shows Euromonitor data.


Thursday, July 26, 2012

Policy-LAND ACQUISITION ACT: CHANGE NEEDED

Violence, Protests and Controversies have always Surrounded Land Acquisition in India. The Latest spate of Violent Clashes at Bhatta-Parsaul in UP over Acquisition of Farmers’ land has only brought to fore The Urgent need for Amendments to The Existing Archaic law. 

Another bone of contention is property valuation. The techniques being flawed, there are claims that given a chance, land owners let go of no opportunity to demand higher values for their backyards than the real market value. This, using the much debatable concepts of ‘potential value’ and ‘opportunity value’ of their property. The government claims that this results in a huge strain on public finances and restrictions on the scale of development and re-development projects. There is also an opposition to the additional payment of solatium over the property value (which is a form of compensation for emotional than physical discomfort or financial loss).

People who argue that the act is draconian, claim that a number of projects with no public purpose attached, as in the case of SEZs, have also resulted in land being snatched away from property owners, with the help of the Act. That too, at well below market value. And preachers of market-based solutions cite evidences proving how even in the case of projects that are genuinely meant for public purposes, there have almost always existed a considerable difference between the market value of the property and the value that the land acquisition officer paid the land owners. Blame is also imposed on the authorities of not following up adequately on the issues of relocation and rehabilitation of land owners displaced by the actions of the Act. While speaking with B&E on this matter, CPM leader and MP Nilotpaul Basu, says, “There is absolutely no mention or recognition of the crucial resettlement and rehabilitation policies in the exisiting legislation which makes confrontations inevitable.”

The protests over acquisition of land had until now been an executive premise of the civil society. Despite huge ruckus (and many heartbreaks) over which political party scores over the other in terms of the huge vote banks that the farmers and landowners command, surprisingly, there is also a form of consensus emerging between these very parties over what the current legislation falls short of. Following the incidences that have occurred in the past month, all major political parties, seem to have woken up to realise that the contours of the more-than-a-century-old legislation are outdated and that either the political cartographers must do something urgent in the name of amendments or the clause should be totally scrapped. In their discussions with B&E, Salman Khurshid (the Union Minister for Minority Affairs), Shahnawaz Hussain (a BJP spokesperson), Ajit Singh (Founder & Chief, Rashtriya Lok Dal & a prominent leader of the farmers) and Nilotpaul Basu (Senior CPM leader & MP), all took a similar stand, denouncing the “mess” of a land act that we inherited from the British, and terming the exisiting law as obsolete. Amendments to the Act, as per them, is an immediate and necessary need. The BJP even assures the government of full support in Parilament when the new Bill comes up for discussion. “We are even ready for a special session of Parliament to get the Bill approved, provided it is in favour of the farmers,” says BJP’s Shahnawaz to B&E.




Wednesday, July 25, 2012

We’re Happily Fired!

The Trend of Senior CIA Officials leaving The Agency is a Security Issue

The CIA proudly defines itself as the “Work of a Nation, the Centre of Intelligence”. But the brain drain within the Intelligence agency is a phenomenon that diminishes the connotation for the same. The trend of officers leaving CIA has gone up, especially after 9/11. According to data compiled by the Washington Post, about 91 upper-level CIA officials have left the agency in order to find a lucrative job in private sector since 9/11.

This evidently is an expensive trend for the US government. The huge money, time and energy invested for decades of experience and training, paid for by US taxpayers, comes to naught when officials leave for private employment. Most of these senior officials have assumed lucrative posts with private intelligence firms and security consultants, often making significantly more than they could ever make working at the CIA. A major migration to the private sector was witnessed during 2002-07, as business with intelligence contractors increased. However, in 2010, attrition rates at CIA were at an all time low, as quoted by an intelligence official in media. Apparently, out of 8,54,000 Americans with top-secret clearances, 2,65,000 are now employees of private contractors.

The reasons are many. Firstly, CIA is flexible allowing its employees leverage to join private firms. Secondly, the private intelligence industry has emerged as an extremely profitable and large industry, especially after the Iraq and Afghan invasion and war on terror. Thirdly, the financial leg-up appears to be significant enough for the ex-CIA personnel to accommodate some compromises on putting the nation first. While the average salary of the top CIA personnel remains around $180,000 annually, private firms are easily able to offer more.